Calc ₳ Phos: Difference between revisions

From Wikihomeopathy
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (1 revision imported)
No edit summary
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
=== Similar ===
=== Similar ===
Both are useful in [[Ichthyosis remedies|ichthyosis]]


* Both are useful in [[Ichthyosis remedies|ichthyosis]]
* The dominant character in both remedies is FEAR (Illness, fear of death, fear of calamity). Special fears
** Fear that people will realize one's mental confusion (Calc)
** Fear of storm (Phos)
*


=== Difference ===
== Mind ==
[[Calc-c, Calcerea carbonica|Calc]]
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!
!Calc
!Phos
!
|-
|Affections caused by
|vexation + Fear, caused by bad news
|Anger, fear or vexation with vehemence
|
|-
|Sociability, improvement in society
|
|
|
|-
|Incapacity for prolonged mental effort
|
|
|
|}


[[Phos, Phosphorus|Phos]]
== Generality ==
 
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!
!Calc
!Phos
!
|-
|Weakness, Exhausted at the slightest effort
|
* Calc begins to sweat profusely, esp from his head.
* After sex Calc is exhausted / Back weakness
|
* Phos is suitable for weak, tall, thin subjects who have grown too quickly.
* Phos is not capable of prolonged physical exertion. He gets tired very quickly.
|
|-
|Relaxed tissues
|
* Calc: Everything is relaxed ( Muscles / Soft flabby tissues) (Hemorrhoids, Varicose veins, Penis)
|Phos has also uterus prolapse, Anus remains wide open. Sexual impotence after sexual excesses
|
|-
|Partial coldness
|
* Very characteristic of Calc
* Calc: Cold sensation in the vertex
* Sensation of heat in the vertex = Sul
|Sensation of cold in the occiput 
|
|-
|Anemia/ Bleeding
|
|Anemia/ Bleed easily from the nose, gums, periods/ Prolonged purpura
|
|-
|Congestive (Sul, Lach)
|
* Congestive / Throbbing headache which amel with hot applications
* Heat feet at night. (Sometimes) Therefore, do not give Sul too systematically
|
* Congestive / Throbbing headache which amel with cold applications
* Unilateral heat sensation right side = Phos
|
|-
|CVA
|
* Blood apoplexy
|Nervous apoplexy
|
|-
|Epilepsy
|
* Epilepsy with loss of consciousness 
|Epilepsy with preservation of consciousness
|
|-
|Puls
|
* Calc's pulse is full, and rapid
|Phosp's pulse is variable, irregular, sometimes intermittent. Most often it is fast, full and hard
|
|-
|Chilly
|Feeling cold, shivering after Sleep /Breakfast
|Sensation of increased heat after breakfast
|
|-
|Sweating
|Increased sweating during meals
|Decreased sweating during meals
|
|-
|
|First feel hot, then get cold. Constant thirst
|Begins by feeling cold, then heat. Thirst is not constant
|
|-
|pupil
|Dilated pupil:
|Miosis
|
|-
|Destructive nature
|
|
* Esp in spinal cord and nerves (Paralysis)
* Bones, destruction
* Rbc with jaundice by hemolysis
* Blood vessels (purpura);
* Fatty degeneration of the heart, liver, kidneys
|
|-
|Mucous membranes
| colspan="2" |Esp Eyes, Nostrils, Ears, Respiratory tract , Keratitis/ Conjunctivitis 
|
|-
|Cataract (Calc-i is the best remedy)
| colspan="2" |Common
|
|-
|secretions
|Yellow
|Greenish-yellow and bloody.
|
|-
|Age
|Calc is more often indicated in children and young women than in the elderly.
|Phos (Like Ars) more often indicated in the elderly, which does not mean that it is not indicated in children (the same for Ars).
|
|-
|Character
|
* Facial emaciation
* Dazedness
* Right side
|
*  Cerebral excitation 
*  Washing of hands
* Left side
|
|}
 
== Physical ==
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!
!
!
!
|-
|Exostosis
|
* EXOSTOSIS is extremely characteristic of Calc and in other places Rickets, scoliosis.
* Fontanelle is slow to close (Nat-m delay is more intellectual than physical, while in Calc delay is linked to physical weakness).
|
|
|-
|Necrosis
Osteomyelitis
|
* Upper jaw
* Bone epiphyses
|
* Lower jaw
* Bone diaphyses
|
|-
|Lymphadenopathy
|
|Esp after trauma
|
|-
|polyps
| colspan="2" |Both have polyps almost everywhere, in the nostrils, ears, bladder, vagina etc
|
|-
|Ear
|Inner ear
|Outer ear
|
|-
|Laryngitis
|Calc is painless,
|Phos is painful. Esp in tuberculous laryngitis
|
|-
|leukorrhea
|not irritating.
|
|
|-
|Abscess
|Abscesses of Calc are deeply located and it is very characteristic (Calc-s).
|
|
|-
|Lip swelliing
|Swelling of the upper lip
|Swelling below the lower eyelids
|
|}
 
== Food ==
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!
!Calc
!Phos
|-
| rowspan="2" |Desire/ Aversion
|
*
 
* Eggs Desire
* Bread Desire
|
* Salt Desire
* Bread Aversion (Nat-m)
|-
| colspan="2" |
* Desire for ice cream and frozen drinks
* Aversion to hot foods
|}
 
 
== Modalities ==
{| class="wikitable"
|Both
|'''Calc'''
|'''Phos'''
|-
|
|Remission of symptoms before midnight.
|'''Remission of symptoms after midnight'''
|-
|Cold agg
|
|
|-
|
|Humidity agg
|Before and during storm agg
|-
|
|Open air agg
|Outdoors amel
|-
|
|New moon/ Full moon agg
|
|-
|
|Leaning forward agg
|Leaning forward amel
|-
|
|Lying on side agg
|Lying on side amel
|-
|
|Standing up straight amel
|Standing up straight agg
|-
|
|Lying on your back amel
|Lying on your back agg
|-
|
|Position changes amel
|Position changes agg
|-
|
|Movement agg
|Agg at the beginning of the movement, amel by continued movement.
|-
|
|After meal agg
|After meal amel
|-
|
|Hot foods amel or agg
|'''Always agg by Hot foods'''
|-
|Company amel
|
|
|-
|Pressure agg
|
|
|-
|
|Lying on the diseased part amel
|Lying on the diseased part agg
|-
|
|Little influenced by touching.
|Touching agg
|-
|Massages amel
|
|
|}
<blockquote></blockquote>
{| class="wikitable"
|'''CALCAREA CARB.'''
|'''PHOSPHORUS'''
|-
|'''REGION:Nutrition: glands, bones, skin.The blood.Chest.''' Right lung
'''The heart.'''
'''The children.'''
|'''REGION:The cavities:'''- ''Head'' ,
- '''lungs''' ,
- ''heart'' .
 
'''Circulation''' : ''blood'' , '''blood vessels''' .
'''The mucous membranes- stomach,- intestines,'''- Lungs (bases).
'''The nerves''' :
- ''the brain,''
''- the spinal cord'' .
''The bones'' :
- Jaw (upper),
- chin,
- spine.
Liver.
|-
|'''AGGRAVATIONS:'''from the '''cold''' :
- '''brisk air; humidity''' ,
- '''bathing''' ,
 
- Changes in weather,
- Cooling.
'''Through exercises''' :
- mental,
- physical.
- ascension,
- eye muscles.
'''Dentition. PubertyPressure from clothing''' .
Milk. While waking up. Anxiety.
|'''AGGRAVATIONS:When lying down:- on the left side''' or on the painful side,
''- on the side'' ,
- on the back.
'''The slightest cause:'''
'''- emotions,'''- speaking,
- touch.
- the smells.
- the light.
'''Cold:- hands''' (in water).
- in the fresh air.
'''Hot foods.'''Salt. Puberty. ''Sexual excesses'' .
 
''Time'' :
- change of time. suddenly.
- ''The wind, the cold.''
''- The storm.Morning and evening.Brain fatigue.''
|-
|'''IMPROVEMENTS''' :
|'''IMPROVEMENTS''' :
 
''After meals'' . The sleep.
 
Cold. Food, water in the face.
 
Through massages (magnetism).
 
When getting up from a sitting position.
|}
 
 
 
 
 
 
*
 
*
 
*
 
 
 
   

Latest revision as of 10:15, 5 February 2024

Similar

  • Both are useful in ichthyosis
  • The dominant character in both remedies is FEAR (Illness, fear of death, fear of calamity). Special fears
    • Fear that people will realize one's mental confusion (Calc)
    • Fear of storm (Phos)

Mind

Calc Phos
Affections caused by vexation + Fear, caused by bad news Anger, fear or vexation with vehemence
Sociability, improvement in society
Incapacity for prolonged mental effort

Generality

Calc Phos
Weakness, Exhausted at the slightest effort
  • Calc begins to sweat profusely, esp from his head.
  • After sex Calc is exhausted / Back weakness
  • Phos is suitable for weak, tall, thin subjects who have grown too quickly.
  • Phos is not capable of prolonged physical exertion. He gets tired very quickly.
Relaxed tissues
  • Calc: Everything is relaxed ( Muscles / Soft flabby tissues) (Hemorrhoids, Varicose veins, Penis)
Phos has also uterus prolapse, Anus remains wide open. Sexual impotence after sexual excesses
Partial coldness
  • Very characteristic of Calc
  • Calc: Cold sensation in the vertex
  • Sensation of heat in the vertex = Sul
Sensation of cold in the occiput
Anemia/ Bleeding Anemia/ Bleed easily from the nose, gums, periods/ Prolonged purpura
Congestive (Sul, Lach)
  • Congestive / Throbbing headache which amel with hot applications
  • Heat feet at night. (Sometimes) Therefore, do not give Sul too systematically
  • Congestive / Throbbing headache which amel with cold applications
  • Unilateral heat sensation right side = Phos
CVA
  • Blood apoplexy
Nervous apoplexy
Epilepsy
  • Epilepsy with loss of consciousness
Epilepsy with preservation of consciousness
Puls
  • Calc's pulse is full, and rapid
Phosp's pulse is variable, irregular, sometimes intermittent. Most often it is fast, full and hard
Chilly Feeling cold, shivering after Sleep /Breakfast Sensation of increased heat after breakfast
Sweating Increased sweating during meals Decreased sweating during meals
First feel hot, then get cold. Constant thirst Begins by feeling cold, then heat. Thirst is not constant
pupil Dilated pupil: Miosis
Destructive nature
  • Esp in spinal cord and nerves (Paralysis)
  • Bones, destruction
  • Rbc with jaundice by hemolysis
  • Blood vessels (purpura);
  • Fatty degeneration of the heart, liver, kidneys
Mucous membranes Esp Eyes, Nostrils, Ears, Respiratory tract , Keratitis/ Conjunctivitis
Cataract (Calc-i is the best remedy) Common
secretions Yellow Greenish-yellow and bloody.
Age Calc is more often indicated in children and young women than in the elderly. Phos (Like Ars) more often indicated in the elderly, which does not mean that it is not indicated in children (the same for Ars).
Character
  • Facial emaciation
  • Dazedness
  • Right side
  •  Cerebral excitation
  •  Washing of hands
  • Left side

Physical

Exostosis
  • EXOSTOSIS is extremely characteristic of Calc and in other places Rickets, scoliosis.
  • Fontanelle is slow to close (Nat-m delay is more intellectual than physical, while in Calc delay is linked to physical weakness).
Necrosis

Osteomyelitis

  • Upper jaw
  • Bone epiphyses
  • Lower jaw
  • Bone diaphyses
Lymphadenopathy Esp after trauma
polyps Both have polyps almost everywhere, in the nostrils, ears, bladder, vagina etc
Ear Inner ear Outer ear
Laryngitis Calc is painless, Phos is painful. Esp in tuberculous laryngitis
leukorrhea not irritating.
Abscess Abscesses of Calc are deeply located and it is very characteristic (Calc-s).
Lip swelliing Swelling of the upper lip Swelling below the lower eyelids

Food

Calc Phos
Desire/ Aversion
  • Eggs Desire
  • Bread Desire
  • Salt Desire
  • Bread Aversion (Nat-m)
  • Desire for ice cream and frozen drinks
  • Aversion to hot foods


Modalities

Both Calc Phos
Remission of symptoms before midnight. Remission of symptoms after midnight
Cold agg
Humidity agg Before and during storm agg
Open air agg Outdoors amel
New moon/ Full moon agg
Leaning forward agg Leaning forward amel
Lying on side agg Lying on side amel
Standing up straight amel Standing up straight agg
Lying on your back amel Lying on your back agg
Position changes amel Position changes agg
Movement agg Agg at the beginning of the movement, amel by continued movement.
After meal agg After meal amel
Hot foods amel or agg Always agg by Hot foods
Company amel
Pressure agg
Lying on the diseased part amel Lying on the diseased part agg
Little influenced by touching. Touching agg
Massages amel
CALCAREA CARB. PHOSPHORUS
REGION:Nutrition: glands, bones, skin.The blood.Chest. Right lung

The heart. The children.

REGION:The cavities:- Head ,

- lungs , - heart .

Circulation : blood , blood vessels . The mucous membranes- stomach,- intestines,- Lungs (bases). The nerves : - the brain, - the spinal cord . The bones : - Jaw (upper), - chin, - spine. Liver.

AGGRAVATIONS:from the cold :

- brisk air; humidity , - bathing ,

- Changes in weather, - Cooling. Through exercises : - mental, - physical. - ascension, - eye muscles. Dentition. PubertyPressure from clothing . Milk. While waking up. Anxiety.

AGGRAVATIONS:When lying down:- on the left side or on the painful side,

- on the side , - on the back. The slightest cause: - emotions,- speaking, - touch. - the smells. - the light. Cold:- hands (in water). - in the fresh air. Hot foods.Salt. Puberty. Sexual excesses .

Time : - change of time. suddenly. - The wind, the cold. - The storm.Morning and evening.Brain fatigue.

IMPROVEMENTS : IMPROVEMENTS :

After meals . The sleep.

Cold. Food, water in the face.

Through massages (magnetism).

When getting up from a sitting position.