Clinging vs Carried desire: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
=== Definition === | === Definition === | ||
* Both are [[Sehgal Rubrics]] | |||
* Both are [[Sehgal | * [[Sehgal]] has a good differentiation between these two rubrics | ||
* | {| class="wikitable" | ||
|+ | |||
* Cling patient is | !Carried | ||
!Clinging | |||
|- | |||
|Carried is a [[Sehgal Second Degree Rubrics|Sehgal Second Degree Rubric]] | |||
|Clinging is a [[Sehgal First Degree Rubrics|Sehgal First Degree Rubric]] | |||
|- | |||
| | |||
* When someone wants to be carried by others. He asks them to be carried continuously. He does not do anything only begging. He does not touch anybody only repeating his request | |||
* Carried uses "Desire" NOT "Want" which means fewer necessity. | |||
| | |||
*Cling patient is someone who is attached to you. | |||
*Clinging means Sticking tightly with no idea of leaving it as long as one's faith allows it. It is much more stronger than Carrying. | |||
|- | |||
|Carry has a hide concept of moving but Cling has not. It means that the patient needs support for becoming or achieving a goal. | |||
|Cling means the patient feels very insecure, which makes him cling to Someone / Something not necessarily for becoming but also for being | |||
|- | |||
|Carried means Pulled, Pushed, Induced by an external stimuli such as Remedy / Advice / Doctor | |||
|He clings your personality/ Specialty / Kindness / Energy. In this situation the patient insist on his desire and do not leave you even if you disclaim him | |||
|- | |||
|In adults he may tell the doctor, I do not know why, but I think you should cure me. You should give me a good medicine | |||
|The patient says, I will not leave you until you make me better / Cure | |||
|- | |||
|Carried desire is a patient that request your treatment / Protection. So first he ask you then come to visit you | |||
|cling patient does not ask you, he come and do not leave you until complete treatment | |||
|- | |||
|Carried has sub-rubrics of Fast, Slow and Caressed. All of them linked with movement. | |||
|It has two sub-rubrics | |||
* Clinging, held: The patient praise you. He tells that you are the best doctor and he does not leave you until complete treatment. \ | |||
* "Clinging, to persons or furniture" is a [[Sehgal First Degree Rubrics|Sehgal First Degree Rubric.]] It differ from Clinging which has no extra words, which means the patient has not been located in the situation of clinging yet. | |||
|} | |||
=== Remedies === | === Remedies === | ||
* Both [[Gels, Gelsemium sempervirens|Gels]] and [[Stram, Stramonium|Stram]] has clinging. But the underlying reason is different. | * Both [[Gels, Gelsemium sempervirens|Gels]] and [[Stram, Stramonium|Stram]] has clinging. But the underlying reason is different. | ||
* [[Stram, Stramonium|Stram]] is freighted | ** [[Stram, Stramonium|Stram]] is freighted and that's why he clings you. | ||
** [[Gels, Gelsemium sempervirens|Gels]] understands that you are an appropriate person and could help him. He wants positive light. He clings you because you told him that you can Help / Cure him. He clings you because of your assurance. So when you tell him that there is no cure, he will leave you. Gels need reassurance continuously. | |||
=== Rubrics === | === Rubrics === | ||
| Line 19: | Line 46: | ||
* Clinging, Persons or furniture: Bar-c, Borx, Cina, Gels, Phos, Puls, Stram | * Clinging, Persons or furniture: Bar-c, Borx, Cina, Gels, Phos, Puls, Stram | ||
* Clinging, children, awaken, terrified: Borx, Stram | * Clinging, children, awaken, terrified: Borx, Stram | ||
* Carries desire: Cham, | * Carries desire: Ars, Bell, Cham, Cina, Kali-c, lyc, Puls, Stram, Sul, Verat | ||
* Carries desire, | * Carries desire, fast: Ars, bell, Verat | ||
* Carries desire, slowly: Puls | * Carries desire, slowly: Puls | ||
* Carries desire and Caressed: Acon, Cham, Kreos, Puls | |||
Revision as of 23:20, 11 May 2024
Definition
- Both are Sehgal Rubrics
- Sehgal has a good differentiation between these two rubrics
| Carried | Clinging |
|---|---|
| Carried is a Sehgal Second Degree Rubric | Clinging is a Sehgal First Degree Rubric |
|
|
| Carry has a hide concept of moving but Cling has not. It means that the patient needs support for becoming or achieving a goal. | Cling means the patient feels very insecure, which makes him cling to Someone / Something not necessarily for becoming but also for being |
| Carried means Pulled, Pushed, Induced by an external stimuli such as Remedy / Advice / Doctor | He clings your personality/ Specialty / Kindness / Energy. In this situation the patient insist on his desire and do not leave you even if you disclaim him |
| In adults he may tell the doctor, I do not know why, but I think you should cure me. You should give me a good medicine | The patient says, I will not leave you until you make me better / Cure |
| Carried desire is a patient that request your treatment / Protection. So first he ask you then come to visit you | cling patient does not ask you, he come and do not leave you until complete treatment |
| Carried has sub-rubrics of Fast, Slow and Caressed. All of them linked with movement. | It has two sub-rubrics
|
Remedies
- Both Gels and Stram has clinging. But the underlying reason is different.
- Stram is freighted and that's why he clings you.
- Gels understands that you are an appropriate person and could help him. He wants positive light. He clings you because you told him that you can Help / Cure him. He clings you because of your assurance. So when you tell him that there is no cure, he will leave you. Gels need reassurance continuously.
Rubrics
- Clinging, Persons or furniture: Bar-c, Borx, Cina, Gels, Phos, Puls, Stram
- Clinging, children, awaken, terrified: Borx, Stram
- Carries desire: Ars, Bell, Cham, Cina, Kali-c, lyc, Puls, Stram, Sul, Verat
- Carries desire, fast: Ars, bell, Verat
- Carries desire, slowly: Puls
- Carries desire and Caressed: Acon, Cham, Kreos, Puls