Objective reasonable

From Wikihomeopathy
Revision as of 11:40, 13 April 2025 by Mehrdad (talk | contribs) (→‎Sehgal Remedies)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Definition

  • In “objective reasonable ” it is the reasoning which is very strong. He stresses upon his point as he has valid reasons for it. He likes to be convinced before he agrees to follow something. There has to be a logical background for this patient to talk about. It is more about the logic. He listens and tries to understand but follows it only after he gets convinced about it.
  • A patient says o.k. I will follow your instructions but I must know why I should follow them. If you convince him then he will follow them. I don’t mind going for investigations but you have to tell me what are you suspecting in them. He needs to know if a Dr .has a clear idea as to what he suspects will be the outcome of the investigations. If he gets convinced then he will say o.k. I am convinced and I will go for investigation.

Compare with "Light Aversion /Shuns"

  • A patient is avoiding something because he is not comfortable about it. He will try to justify his point ignoring the point of others on that issue. He wants to avoid it as he feels that it could be possible that something bad will come in the tests. He says, “ still I am living with this impression that there is nothing wrong with me , I won’t be able to survive if I come to know that I am suffering from some ailment.

Sehgal Remedies

Similar Rubrics

Bell

Plat

  • He argues with you to tell you I am right and you are wrong
  • He will argue with you logically to convince you

Lach

  • Lach has perseverance. He believes what he is doing is right. He does not need any suggestions. According to him, he has made very carefully effort to over come his disease and that is why he is right. (Like Nux-v) (Lach ₳ Nux-v)
  • He keeps on complaining and lamenting about his disease and sickness. (Like Nux-v) (Lach ₳ Nux-v)

Hep

Merc

Nat-m

Dictatorial

Sep

Nit-ac

Nux-v

Sehgal added it to this rubric Reason, increased power of

Sil