Bell in Sehgal: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
Line 828: | Line 828: | ||
* Laughing, speaking when | * Laughing, speaking when | ||
* [[Light | * [[Light desire for]] | ||
* [[Mood, repulsive]] | * [[Mood, repulsive]] | ||
Line 854: | Line 854: | ||
| | | | ||
|} | |} | ||
Version 4 | |||
== Version 4 == | |||
{| class="wikitable" | {| class="wikitable" | ||
|+ | |+ | ||
Line 863: | Line 864: | ||
|- | |- | ||
| | | | ||
* Del, wealth of | * [[Delusion, wealth|Del, wealth of]] | ||
* Laughing, speaking when | * Laughing, speaking when | ||
* Calculating inability for | * [[Calculating inability|Calculating inability for]] | ||
* Del, sick being | * [[Delusion, sick being|Del, sick being]] | ||
* | * [[Defiant]] | ||
* Mood, Repulsive | * [[Mood, repulsive|Mood, Repulsive]] | ||
* Serious, earnest | * Serious, earnest | ||
* [[Light desires for]] | * [[Light desires for]] | ||
Line 893: | Line 894: | ||
| | | | ||
|} | |} | ||
Version | |||
== Version 5 == | |||
{| class="wikitable" | {| class="wikitable" | ||
|+ | |+ | ||
Line 904: | Line 906: | ||
* Laughing sneaking when | * Laughing sneaking when | ||
* Carried, desires to be fast | * Carried, desires to be fast | ||
* Del, wealth of (when | * [[Delusion, wealth|Del, wealth of]] (when she is in the normal mood she gives the impression that she has no problem) | ||
* [[Shrieking, alternating with consciousness|Unconsciousness,interrupted by screaming]] | |||
* [[Shrieking, alternating with consciousness|Unconsciousness,]][[ | * [[Delusion poor|Del, poor she is]] | ||
* [[Frivolous]] | |||
* Rest, desire for | |||
* Tranquility, sleep after | |||
* [[Quiet, wants to be repose and tranquility|Quiet, wants to be, repose and tranquillity desires]] | |||
* Hide, things and | |||
* [[Noise inclination to make|Noise inclined to make]] | |||
* [[Feigning sick]] | |||
* [[Light desire for|Light, desire for]] (Likes to keep her mind free of any stress.) | |||
| | | | ||
* Mrs. X 48 nurse from west Indies settled in London. | * Mrs. X 48 nurse from west Indies settled in London. | ||
* Pain in multiple joints, chest extending to left arm and numbness of right hand. Also hypertension, sleeplessness and lassitude. | * Pain in multiple joints, chest extending to left arm and numbness of right hand. Also hypertension, sleeplessness and lassitude. | ||
Line 920: | Line 924: | ||
* Gives a very pleasing look, smiling, laughing. Before waiting for me to question, she starts "I remain tired all the time". | * Gives a very pleasing look, smiling, laughing. Before waiting for me to question, she starts "I remain tired all the time". | ||
* While you observe her talking you will feel that the laughing is coming down to smiling and suddenly ending in seriousness while delivering the words “I remain tired all the time” as if coming out of unawareness about self for a moment to return to the same state immediately thereafter, (just as a bus stops, drops a passenger and takes off gradually to attain swiftness in the end). | * While you observe her talking you will feel that the laughing is coming down to smiling and suddenly ending in seriousness while delivering the words “I remain tired all the time” as if coming out of unawareness about self for a moment to return to the same state immediately thereafter, (just as a bus stops, drops a passenger and takes off gradually to attain swiftness in the end). | ||
* D: Are you attending your job? P: Yes. D: Any problem? P: No. | * D: Are you attending your job? P: Yes. D: Any problem? | ||
* P: No, how is it possible and also I am in the middle of the age, with so many ailments. | |||
* D: How much you feel you have gone down? | |||
* P: Not that bad, I am still doing well. | |||
* D: Do you get good sleep? | |||
* P: No, I wish it. | |||
* D: Do you get fresh after sleep? | |||
* P: Of course, when I really get it and in desperation sometimes I have to take a sleeping pill. | |||
* D: When do you get pains? | |||
* P: Usually in the night and in the evening. D: Daily? | |||
* P: It is with me all the time but within limits but sometimes it becomes unbearable. D: Any periodicity? | |||
* P: No, it has no fixed time. D: What have you to do when it becomes intolerable? P: Lying down. | |||
* D: Do you make noise during the pain? | |||
* D: Laughs and says "ask my husband". D: Is it continuous | |||
* P: It is at intervals. | |||
* D: What is your general mood during the pain? | |||
* P: To remain quiet. | |||
* D: Do you like to talk about your sickness to anyone? | |||
* P: Not always, and to none else than my husband and that too only when he becomes careless about me. | |||
* D: Are you too demanding on him? | |||
* P: Laughingly, in a very light mood she says " No, no, no" not that way. | |||
| | | | ||
| | | |
Revision as of 23:09, 10 April 2025
Bell is one of best Sehgal Remedies which is used commonly in Sehgal Method.
Sehgal Rubrics
Frivolous |
In his opinion one should be strong enough to handle a problem now and then. He says, "I am not a kind of person who rushes to a doctor for minor things." |
Objective, reasonable |
He first waits for the problem to go away without doing anything. He sees a doctor only when it persists.
D: How you expect the problem to be cured on its own, P: it has happened to me several times in the past when a problem vanished itself after a couple of days without a visit to the doctor. P: "I believe that if something bad is destined to happen, it will happen no matter what. It's beyond me or anyone to prevent it. Why should I spoil my peace of mind for something which I don't have any control over or don't even know will happen at all?" |
Unconsciousness, interrupted by screamingIndifference, alt. with sensitiveness |
|
Light, desires for |
After waiting for some time, when he realizes his problem is persisting (despite taking medicines) he tries to look for the cause. |
Delirium, gather objects off the wall, tries toBell, Hyos |
|
Calculating, inability for |
Some of his observation and questions would be:
|
How come this frivolous person takes so much interest in his health?
| |
Fear, everything, constant of |
D: Why did not you take your problem seriously earlier
P: He says with a laugh, "Maybe I failed to calculate how far things could go." What I thought was a minor gastric problem, has grown into a severe one. I never imagined that so small a thing would trouble me so much. |
Del, Wolves of |
One of the reasons why a bell, patient visits a doctor is because he finds his life restricted by sickness and all the fun go out of it.
• |
Del, possessed beingAnger, Himself |
When he Realized that he did not seek help promptly, and let his condition deteriorate, he become angry with himself.
|
Carried desires to be fast |
|
Disease stages
Sehgal Rubrics | |
---|---|
First stage
|
|
Why come to doctor?
|
|
Second stage
|
|
Third stage |
|
Core Theme
Related Rubrics | ||
---|---|---|
Enjoymentis the axis of their life
|
|
|
Hiding, himeself |
|
|
Light |
|
|
Del, Poor |
|
|
Carried, desire, to be, fast |
He desire to get ride of his maladies as fast as possible (Desire, not Want) | Credulous |
NO restrictions |
|
|
Manic stage |
|
|
Timidity |
|
He is a nice child at first. But after two min, he starts:
When you tell him do not do that, He obey only for one minute but soon he tries to do that forbidden thing. |
Frivolous |
|
|
Naive / Credulous |
|
|
Bell child
- Bell dose not like to answer you
- Pompous feeling / Desire for attention of others. He makes noise to Get your attention. Feigning sick
- Carried desire to be but not clinging
Bell / Hyos/ Stram
Hyos | Bell | Stram | |
---|---|---|---|
Bed remain |
+++
|
- - -
|
- - - |
Carried |
- - -
He is suspicious to every one, so dose not trust |
+++
|
+++
|
Cling |
- - -
|
- - - | +++
|
Escape attempt, delirium during |
+++
|
+++
|
+++
|
Well, says he is |
+++ | ||
Calm |
Aggressive, Wild | ||
Dependent |
+++ | +++ | Affectinate, He shows he is dependent |
Affectation |
+++ | --- | +++ |
Good rubrics |
Remedies | ||
---|---|---|---|
FEIGNING sick | Desires attention | Wants someone lying by her side in the bed | Bell, Calc, Lyc, Op, Puls, Verat |
UNCONSCIOUSNESS, interrupted by screaming | Remains calm or normal with short intervals of loud moaning | only Bell | |
|
|||
RAGE; medicine; from forcible administration of (1) | |||
STRIKING; himself, knocking head against wall and things (9) | SELF; torture (7): Acon, ars, bell, lil-t, plb, tarent, tub |
Sehgal Rubrics
Words | Meaning | Versions | Similar Rubrics | |
---|---|---|---|---|
DELUSIONS, sensations, misrepresents hisonly Bell |
|
Unable to communicate one’s feelings correctly. |
|
Gesture makes, Groping as if in Dark: Cocc, Hyos, Op, Stram |
DELUSIONS, business ordinary they are pursuingArs, Bell, Stram |
Business: An occupation or profession.
Thought: Opined, considered. Perusing: Carrying on. Ordinary: Somewhat inferior or below average. |
|
|
Industrious |
DELUSIONS, possessed, beingArs, Bell, Canth, Hyos, Lach, Op, Plat, Sil, Stram, Sul, Verat |
Possessed: Is under the control of some other power.
Is owned by something or someone else and has forfeited the right for independent existence. |
Feels that the person is under the occupation of some other power and has to live and act according to its wishes. |
| |
QUIET, wants to be, repose and tranquility, desiresArn, Bell, Bry, Gels, Kali-c, Lach, Nat-m, Phos, Sul |
Quiet:
Repose: Rest; sleep. Tranquility: Free from or unaffected by any sort of disturbing emotions. |
A person needs rest and is preferably craving for sleep which he feels he can achieve by suspending all activities and work. | Whenever I get tired, I feel like taking rest. To recoup lost energy which I can achieve only in a peaceful atmosphere without any sort of noise | |
DELUSIONS, surrounded by friends, isBell, Hydr-ac |
Surrounded: Encircled, enclosed on all sides.
Friends: Persons attached to one another by feeling or affection or personal regard; a person who is on good terms with another; not hostile. |
Everyone around him seems to be friendly and without any bad design. | I don t see anything bad in any person. All are respectful and affectionate to me. They seem very near me without discrimination. | CREDULOUS
Arg-n, Bar-c, Bell, Puls, Staph |
Exhilaration/ Exuburance |
Exuberance= A state of extreme joy and vigour. | The person remains over joyous which also exhibits his stamina to live within. | I never find him tired of his sense of humor and joy. Whenever he meets you, you will find him full of fun and frolic. | |
MAGNETIZED, desires to be; mesmerism |
Magnetized: Wants to acquire the quality of a magnet i.e. the power of attraction.
Mesmerism: The act of inducing an extraordinary state of the nervous system in which the operator is supposed to control the action and thoughts of the subject. |
Both the rubrics are opposite in sense. Wants to be magnetized, (to be attractive) so as to be able, to attract (charm) others (mesmerism amel.) because it gives satisfaction. The desire is to be the centre of attraction. |
|
|
COMPANY, aversion to, friends, of intimateBell, Cham |
Company: Companionship. Association.
Intimate: Associated in close personal relation. Friend : A person attached to another by feeling of affection. |
Why should one avoid the company of closely related person? It seems he has to hide something which he feels he will not be able to, if he comes closer to anyone. | I don t visit people who are closely known to me because they ask probing questions about my sickness, which I don t like. |
|
ANXIETY, company, when inAcon, Ambr, Bell, Lyc, Plat, Stram |
Anxiety: Discomfort | As long as I remain in the company of others, I am uncomfortable for fear of being asked unpredictable questions esp regarding my sickness. | COMPANY, aversion to, friends, of intimate | |
COQUETTISH, not enoughBell, Lyc, Puls, Staph, Sul |
Coquettish: A male or female who mixes up with the opposite sex freely without any feeling of guilt or shame or serious intentions for marriage etc. | To indulge with the opposite sex innocently without knowing its consequences, but to a negligible extent. | His inclination towards the opposite sex is not sufficient as it should be and that of the younger is more than the normal. | COQUETTISH too much
Ambr, Bell, Lach, Lyc, Nux-v, Phos, Plat, Puls, Sul, Verat |
PLEASURE, lascivious ideas, only inonly Bell |
Pleasure: Enjoyment or satisfaction derived from what is to one’s liking.
Lascivious: Arousing or inciting sexual desires. Ideas: Conceptions existing in the mind as a result of mental understanding. |
There is no other source of enjoyment except concentrating one’s mind on the perceptions exciting sexual desire. | Whenever I come across a beautiful girl I start viewing the attractive organs of her body which ultimately leads me to visualize her sexual organs which arouse my desire for sex. This is the only thing which gives me happiness. | |
UNRELIABLE, promises, in hisBell, Calc, Con, Lyc, Op, Sil, Sul |
Unreliable: One who cannot be depended upon.
Promises: The act of honoring one’s words. |
|
I cannot keep my words, not to take any other medicine because I cannot bear pain and delay in relief. | He makes funny stories to justify his lies. |
WEEPING, remonstrated, whenBell, Calc, Ign, Kali-c, Plat, Puls |
Remonstrated: One who gets pleadings, protests, objections or disapproval of his argument. Defeated in arguments. | When one fails in arguments starts weeping to assert or defend himself. | He cannot stand opposition to his conception of things. When he fails to impress his point he starts weeping to stop others from pressing their views. | |
BOASTER, braggartAcon, Arn, Ars, Bell, Calc, Lach, Lyc, Nat-m, Nux-v, Plat, Puls, Stram, Sul, Verat |
Boaster: A person who speaks about himself with excessive pride and vanity.
Braggart: Who speaks with exaggeration and pride esp about oneself or something connected with oneself. |
One who is excessively proud of one’s personal achievements and possessions and speaks about them with excessive air of self praise. | I can boastfully say that the intensity of pain which I could bear, nobody else could do |
|
Pompous, importantBell, Calc, Hyos, Lyc, Phos, Plat, Stram, Sul Verat |
From the gestures of the patient I noticed that he was trying to pose that he deserves and desires to be treated as a man of dignity and importance | |||
Naive, intelligent but veryBell, Hyos, Stram, Sul, Verat |
Naive:
Intelligent: Sharp in understanding and comprehending. |
|
He has topped in the university so far as his studies are concerned but is so simple in practical dealing that even a child can cheat him.
| |
CredulousArg-n, Bar-c, Bell, Puls, Staph |
|
.
|
| |
Calculating, inability toBell, Calc, Kali-c, Lyc, Nat-m, Nux-v |
Calculating: Assessing the extent of anything.
Inability: Lack of ability, power or capacity. |
Unable to assess things properly and accurately like mathematical calculations.
|
| |
Sensitive, alternating with Indifferenceonly Bell |
They are Light-minded people | Their reaction is a mixture of Fear + Frivolous + Credulous | ||
Benevolence |
|
| ||
Light desire for |
| |||
Objective, reasonableAlum, Bell, Hep, Lach, Merc, Nat-m, Nit-ac, Plat, Sil |
He has always has objection
He asks you for the reason for the restrictions |
- I never need medicine. I am Healthy / Wealthy. But recently I have disease, I do not know from when.
- This malady is bothering me. I want to get rid of it so fast. (Carried desire to fast)
- He wants some remedy to enjoy life again. So he come to you when his enjoyment is hurt
- Bell has squandering on thing for showing off.
- His staring sentence is: I never become so sick, because they feel blessed by God
- I do not like to be sick. I do not understand why people get sick. I have never such an experience.
- He always keep smiling to hide his sickness or because of Frivolous
- He has no program for future. He like Gambling. He is Credulous. You should ask him what do you plan for future? He answers you who have seen tomorrow?
- When I see people who have so much money, I told them why do not enjoy it?
- he tells you I am not worried about my pain, but for my life/ enjoyment
- They do not want spend their money, but only for Show of
- They think God has given them a lot. So They are happy. They have every thing they should have
- The axis of their life is enjoyment
- When they come to doctor? When they have no pleasure. The cannot enjoy and this is alarm for them
- I have a lot of thing but Ii cannot enjoy.
- I cannot not understand sickness, since I have not ben sick yet
- I Know I am cured fast.
- First they want to hide their problem but if their disease hurt their enjoyment and freedom, they present their illness.
- They are always smiling to hide their maladies. Of course they are frivolous
- He is not fearing of future, health or poverty. He is not Jealous or Avarice
- Gambling, passion, make money to: Bell, Calc, Lyc, Mag-m, Merc, Nat-c, Plat, Puls, Staph, Sul
- Naïve: You should not save your money. You should Spend/ Enjoy it
Version 1
|
|
Objective reasonable | D: How come you have decided to visit me?
P: I always like to take homeopathic medicine whenever I have some trouble. For the last many months I did not need to visit the doctor as I was healthy. First I thought of taking allopathic medicine to get quick relief, but I thought to first try homeopathy as I always prefer to take it first in case I get some trouble. P: As you are nearby so I thought of approaching you as my homeopathic doctor whom I used to visit lives far away. P: Please give me some good medicine which can at least bring the problem down if not remove it completely. D: Why you do not take allopathic medicine? P: She laughed and said, "It can give relief for a short period, and as I know and have experience that the problem will come back again." "Also I do not like the taste of allopathic medicine; homoeopathic medicine is nice to take it." P: She asked me if I know what the cause behind the problem is. D: I told her, it could be urinary tract infection due to unhygienic conditions. She mentioned, that it could be as she had used public toilet a day before. |
Version 2
It was 13th of Jan 95 I received a phone call by a patient at my residence. The caller was an old patient now cured.
He said Sir, “I want to give you a trouble". D: What is that? Dear Sir, one of my near relatives is on death bed. Cutting short I told him that this is my lunch time please call me when I will open my surgery. Sir, it is urgent, I don't think he will survive till the opening of your clinic. All right, but the difficulty with me is that at present I am having fever upto 103 degree. I don't think I shall be able to do anything in this condition. Moreover, it is since a year now that I have stopped accepting out - door appointments to reduce the load of work on me. My dear Sir, he said, "We can do one thing, you remain at your place and I shall come to you along with the patient's son. I am confident of your ability. I have personally talked to and observed the patient. Since I am conversant with your method of case taking, I think I shall be able to answer your questions correctly. I am sorry for the inconvenience, he added further but it is worth taking, who knows just a single dose from your hands may give him life and fame to the potential of Homeopathy”. The son of the patient started relating the history. He said, "It is almost a year now that the patient has been suffering from cough with pain in the chest without any relief. He was on allopathic medicine. After investigations in Nov. 94 it was found that he had cancer of the lungs and liver. Since liver was involved the idea of surgical treatment was set aside. Chemotherapy was suggested which was started immediately. After taking the first course of chemotherapy the patient started feeling its very strong adverse effect on his mind on the very next day. For the 1st time in his life he expressed his desire to absent himself from his business for that day. S. What is the matter? He was asked. F. Nothing. Just that I will take rest today |
Comments:
Why I am telling you this, because these situations you may also have to face. You have to be very honest and open with your patient. Don’t involve yourself in a false prestige. If you are open with your patient his confidence, in you, gets more firm If you feel you are not in a position to take up a case you should straight away refuse and apologize for your inability. After all you are also a human being at times you may not be in a position to perform as expected.
|
In the evening when we wanted to discuss with him something about our business.
F: He said no, we will do it tomorrow. S: The next day also he said we will talk about it some other time and gradually day by day the stage came when he totally closed the door for anything to mention about the business. |
Quiet, wants to be repose and tranquillity desires |
And in a few days time we found him occasionally taking to a different type - of mood of talking to himself, "I can't be saved” and would cry out loudly in a state of fright. “I'll die soon, I'll die soon, I'll die soon". |
Unconsciousness, interrupted by screaming
|
And in the end would start weeping when asked what was he talking about, he would quickly wipe out his eyes and say nothing, nothing and try to normalize his mood, and laugh. |
|
The other side-effect of the treatment was that he lost his appetite, an MD in medicine was consulted. He prescribed and changed many medicines which did not work.
Obviously he was not accepting any food. When argued that in the opinion of doctor, he must try to eat something, even if he was not hungry. He would get annoyed at this suggestion and would say, “Do you think I am a fool, I too know that the food is essential for existence but how to eat without any appetite. You want to force things through my throat that I can’t do”. Says with extreme anger. As this state was continuing the time for the next course of chemotherapy arrived |
Mood , repulsive
Admonition, kindly agg. (When his wisdom is being questioned) Rage, medicine from forcible administration of (1) |
The second course took away his sleep. He felt extremely tortured and desperate and started crying as a mad person.
"Bring, me sleep, Bring, me sleep". He was prescribed Tranquilizers and pills for sleeping. Gradually raising the quantity of the drugs. But even the heaviest doses could not help. Instead the over drugging done under the condition of helplessness gave tragic side affect, it disturbed his motor system. His right arm and the leg started jerking very severely which added further to the worsening of the condition of his sleep so strong was the urge for sleep that when at times there came spells of feeling that perhaps he could sleep he would beg everyone to leave his room instantly and put off the lights |
Desire, sleep for tranquillity
Carried , desires to be fast |
But the jerking would not allow the effort to succeed. Within moments after realizing the uselessness of his attempt he will like everyone to come back in his room with the same speed with which they were sent out.
Then he would want each and every member of the family to be in attendance on him. Someone should press his head others his hands and arms and still others his legs and feet etc. |
|
The other problem that developed was the prostration of his prostrate glands. He would get a strong desire for urination very frequently and would like to be helped to the toilet at once. Most of the time the urge for urine would turn out to be false and remorsefully would tell the nurse Oh! I have unnecessarily bothered you.
The other thing is that he lost his speech and hardly could muster a word out of his tongue. The patient was a well to do person and could afford to appoint all types of medical expertise to be available to him at short notice at his residence. He had also developed family relation with them who would oblige him with courtesy calls to console him. |
Del, sensations misrepresents his (1)
|
When someone of them would come to him he would laugh and tell them in a quarreling way, without disturbing his own mind. | Laughing, speaking when
Quarrelsome, without anger Light, desires for Jesting, ridiculous or foolish |
Version 3
|
|
Version 4
|
|
Version 5
|
|
||