Op in Sehgal

From Wikihomeopathy
Revision as of 00:46, 19 March 2025 by Mehrdad (talk | contribs)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
  • Op is one of the best Sehgal remedies which is used commonly in Sehgal Method
  • Dr Sehgal prescribed it for 10 -15% of cases in practice.
  • Op is not known to be so frequently used in practice. It was only after months of hard labor from Dr. Sehgal who not only identified


King pin Rubric

He applied this rubric in cases where a patient says:
  • It is for many days now that there is no relief. How long shall I have to wait?
  • There should be some relief at least to encourage me
  • On what basis to wait any further?

Fear, extravagance

  • This fear is not only limited to his sickness but also be related to other aspects like finance. E.g before starting the treatment Op patient can ask about the total cost of the treatment. If the cost is within his limit then he won’t mind but if he thinks that it is much than his limit he would say it to be too much.
  • P:I did not expect the fee to be that much in Homeopathy
  • I chose Homoeopathic treatment thinking that it will be much cheaper than allopathy.
  • He probably had an idea that homoeopathy takes long time to cure but still will be cheaper than allopathy
  • He may further enquire about the time span the treatment will take. He will calculate that though the fee is high yet period of treatment is short. He will satisfy himself thinking that it is the matter of 2-3 months, but if told that treatment will last between 6-8 months he may get frightened.
  • Thinking that there is no other option than to agree upon the terms he may put a question “Sir, are you sure that after 6 months of treatment my problem could be solved.”
  • A patient says: “I fear taking homoeopathic medicine because it first increases the problem. I won’t be able to bear it as I already have so many problems.” Any further addition would be an excess for me."
A patient asks, how long shall it take and how much shall he has to pay for the treatment.

Entering channels

1

Indifference, complain does not

Hyos, Stram (Hyos ₳ Op), (Op ₳ Stram)

First stage: He does not want to visit doctor since
  1. Danger, No sense of: Hep, Merc,Op, Plat, Stram, Tub
  2. Well, says, sick very: (Arn, Hyos) (Hyos ₳ Op)
    • Wait and watch until his Red-limit. He has limit for everything.
    • It was not a big issue. I could tolerate it. My parents/ Family send me to you. It is small matter, I can handle it by myself.
  3. Asking, nothing for: Ars, Bry, Cocc, Hyos, Op, Puls
  4. Contentment, Quiet (1): Not to show anybody, Not to complain. He is satisfied
  5. Complaining, Never (1)
2

Fear Extravagance

King Pin rubric

Second stage:
  • Fancies, frightful: Delusions, Image, phantoms, sees (Gels, Hyos, Stram, Bell, Calc, Sul)
  • When disease crosses my limits. It causes me more trouble
  • He fears, if he does not do anything, it could become dangerous.
3

Groping as if in dark

Croc, Hyos, Plb

Third stage:
  • Irresolution, Directionless
  • He does not know which problem is more important and he should discuss it with the doctor, so he does not go to the doctor. (Hyos ₳ Op)
  • I had many problems, therefore I became confused and did not do anything
  • Now I am here, but I do not know, how could I explain my problems. Please ask me every thing you need.
  • He cannot decide what to do? Which of his complains are more important? What can I do?
  • He come to doctor, with some one recommendation
  • Op needs help in decision for every step. He tells you Doctor, how can I use your remedies today. If I can use food supplements? Any Diet? Physical activity? etc
4

Discouraged alternating with hope

Kali-c, Merc, Op, Staph

  • I had a very bad experience with homeopathy but I see one of friend that have not agg
  • So now I want to visit you.
5

Alert

Cautious

  • He is alert and check you if there would be Increased
  • Doctor: I do not tolerate any aggravation. Please do not prescribe any medicine that increase my disease. I am telling you clearly (He emphasizes)
  • Although he has the rubric Gesture make, Groping as if in the dark
6

Noise, inclination to make

Delusion, disorder, objects appear in

  • He is never satisfied with your medicine
  • He tells you, I had 4 disease but you cure one of them. You do not cure the most important problem .
  • He emphasize on his request. He is a bad patient
  • Delusion, disorder, objects appear in (Only op): I do not like to know any thing about Homeopathy and you have promised and you do not do your job properly. All you do is in disorder
7

Business, talks of

  • Because of my disease, I could not go to work in these 3 days. But tomorrow is the forth day, and my disease is still continuing, that I will not able to go to work for the forth day, which is cannot tolerated.
  • He talks with you, as if he is in a business with you.
  • Alert
  • Noise, inclination to make
8

Superstitious

9

Self Reproach

Delirium, blames himself for his folly (1)

Other Rubrics

Noise, inclined to make a

Business, talks of

  • He keeps on reminding the Doctor about the period fixed by him for his treatment. In a curt tone he says: “ It is nearly 5 months now and my condition has not improved much.
  • What is the matter? You have told me that in 6 months time there would be complete cure. Leave apart the cure there is not even 50% improvement.” When tried to console him saying that at least there is 50 % improvement he won’t agree to it and may say, “But we settled for full cure. It is your responsibility to give me complete recovery. I have already paid you too much and spent 6 months with you. It is enough now. You have to treat me free of cost.
  • I am not going to pay you a single penny more. In the above example
  • we can see how an excess of time or payment produced a fear in the mind of the patient.
Timidity, business, transacting in (1) P: (Irritated): I am fed up with my problem. There is no relief from any medicine. I don’t know how long I shall have to bear it.

Embarrassed ailments after

Fear, extravagance, of

  • Embarrassment comes after the patient experiences some problem and when he thinks about that problem, e.g. how painful it was, and if that pain would recur it would be difficult for him to bear.
  • What is representing fear in the above version is: “How long?” This patient is fearful at the thought how long this condition will prevail.

Groping as if in the dark

D: What is your problem? P: I fail to understand what is my problem? Before visiting you I was in a dilemma to decide what would I tell you.?

D: As a patient you must know what is your problem? P: I could tell you if I had a single problem. I have so many problems. I don’t know from where to start.?

D: You have to tell me at least what kind of problem do you have? If you are not so clear you can tell me about its nature, location or modality.

P: Sits quietly, looking towards the doctor as if searching for the words..

D: Please tell me something about your problems? P: I don’t know from where to start. It would be better for me if you ask me whatever information you need from me. I may be perhaps able to answer your questions.

D: Is it related to pain, digestion or sleep etc.

P: I can’t tell you exactly but I think it is related to all of them.

D: Which do you think is the main trouble?

P: I think at present it is mainly related to my stomach at present.

D: What is the problem with your stomach?

P: Loss of appetite, hyperacidity, sour eructation, and pain after eating.

D: Any other problem associated therewith?

Embarrassed,

ailments, after

Indifference, complain does not

Indifference suffering, to

Well, says he is, when very sick

P: I think these are enough to trouble me. I am fed up with them. I think you first start treatment for my loss of appetite. D: Why.?

P: Other problems don’t give me trouble that much. I have no complaint about them. Though sometimes I get a little bit of trouble from them in my, day to day life. But it is Ok.

  • Op patient does not bother for the suffering he gets due to his sickness but his main concern is to stop further increase of the sickness. It is his psyche that he keeps on ignoring his ailment till it is under the limit. The moment he notices that it is going beyond limit he gets frightened. Then he rushes to the Doctor.

Superstitious

P: My stomach problems are the ones troubling me a lot. For a few days I have noticed that it has been increasing day by day and now I have a fear that if it not controlled at this stage, it will increase further.

P: Secondly I have a belief that once my appetite is restored then my other problems would be solved automatically.

D: How can you say that once your appetite is restored all your other problems will be cured?

P: I believe that it is the root cause of my problems. From my childhood I am told that if our digestive system functions properly then our other systems in the body also function properly. Sir I have seen many people who are enjoying good health because their stomach works perfectly.

D: So you think that you are sick because of your stomach upset?

P: Yes, I think so. I don’t know if you believe in it but I have experienced that when I eat properly the whole day I keep very fresh. According to the Medical science it is also relevant that stomach upset can cause many problems. But we have to understand that he is a patient not a medical professional. Means his judgment is purely a hypothetical one. He believes upon those facts which he has heard or seen but has no firm reasons to prove it.

Discouraged, alternating with hope

Clinging, grasp

P: I am not going to continue the treatment further if there won’t be any relief.

D: This you have already said to me during last visit.

P: Sir, every time I visit you hoping that you may be able to select a right remedy. After taking medicine for 3-4 days when I see no improvement I get discouraged. Then I decide to not visit you again. But on not seeing any other alternative, I decided to visit you again with the same old hope of getting a right remedy.

  • It is due to Groping in the dark that he won’t be able to leave the Doctor in spite of discouragement. He keeps on clinging to the Dr. because of the hope given to him by someone.
  • Op is the only common remedy of these three rubrics.

Clinging, grasp

Business, talks of

  • Op clings after he gets some relief but with a time frame. He will wait for some time for further relief.
  • When he realizes that there is no further progress he starts complaining about it irritatingly . He will say:" Sir, initially your medicine worked very well now it is not working. I have a doubt that you are not giving me the same medicine for want of money." “Otherwise how could it be possible that with one day’s medicine I got 15% relief and after that the relief is just 10% in 1 month?”

D: You have so much faith in me?

P: My friend told me a lot about you. I don’t know but the way he praised about you gave me faith that you can help me.

D: How long did you continue the last treatment?

P: Last treatment I continued for 2 weeks. I left it as I did not find any change in 2 weeks. I asked the Doctor what to do? That Doctor advised me to consult a good gastroenterologist I asked him to refer me to a good gastroenterologist as I had no knowledge about that. He told me about one. Meanwhile I met this friend who referred me to you.

D: How long you think you can continue with a Doctor?

P: Approx 10-15 days.

D: Do you think that 10-15 days are sufficient to cure your problem?

P: I don’t mean that in 10 -15 days all my problems will be cured. But I expect some relief at least this period. Sir if there is not a 1 % relief after investing money and spending my valuable time I don’t think it is worth to continue the treatment. I understand my problem is chronic and is liable to take some time. Sir, but a small amount of relief is what convinces one for further positive progress.

Irritability, Pain during

Embarrassed ailments after

Rest, Desire for

Del, disorder, objects appear in

D: How do you take your problem?

P: I am getting very irritated by it. I am fed up with it. I can’t take it any more.

D: What irritates you? P: The long period I am living with it. I need a break from it. I wish this process stops for a few days. I don’t mind if it comes again after a few days.

D: Anything else? P: I don’t know what kind of a problem I am suffering from.

D: What do you mean?

P: I have seen cases like this. After some period of treatment they get cured. I don’t know what is the matter with me? I had taken regular treatment and was very particular about taking the medicine in time. I did exactly as I was instructed by the Doctor. I have been after taking such precautions if a person keeps on suffering from his problem it is indeed a major disorder. I have a feeling that either I am failing to explain my problem to the Doctor or Doctors have failed to understand my problem. There is something missing due to which my problem

This patient feels very strongly that there is some disorder, means things are not coming to an order in spite of all the efforts he has been making.

Cautious

Fear, extravagance

D: Are you taking so many precautions on your own Or you have been asked by the Doctors to take precautions?

P: It is both ways. I myself am now very much concerned about my sickness. Though I am very fond of eating good food even then I take utmost precaution not to eat anything wrong in parties. taking lots of precaution. I left eating spicy and oily things. I completely switched over to vegetarian food. I don’t use alcohol. D: It means you are very strict with your diet?

P: Someday I do eat but in a very small quantity.

D: Is it o.k. for you to eat in small quantity?

P: This is the one thing which irritates me the most. Even a small quantity of oily and spicy food is intolerant to my stomach. Mostly I get problem from that.

D: Why you take risk when you know it precipitates your problem.

P: After all I am also a human being. Sometimes I do get tempted when I see sumptuous foods served at some party. Another reason is that I feel very low when any body questions me the reason for not eating.? I can’t tell them that I have such a problem. To avoid such a situation I take a little bit. Side by side the recovery of my stomach is also tested. I think that when I have not eaten any oily and spicy thing for such a long period let me see that I don’t get any problem. With fear in my mind I try a little bit only. But mostly it ends up with the problem. Sir, I am waiting for the day when I get completely cured.

Gluttony / Bulimia

Sometimes by chance nothing happens, I re-try then. But after repeating for 2-3 times I stop eating more. Internally there is a strong feeling that still there are a plenty of foods left to taste. Yesterday I ate small food at a party. Today I have the problem. I do not tell about it to any body in my family.

Delirium, blames himself for his folly

Reproaches, himself

D: Why you ate when you knew it could trouble you?

P: I am also cursing myself for it. You can say it my foolishness. I thought I have to visit you tomorrow. Just to check if still I am having the problem whenever I eat things. The whole night I had a terrible pain in my stomach. I was accusing myself for my condition. All night I had one thing in my mind that what a foolish thing I have done.

Key words

  • Tolerate: First he told me something, I tolerate, but now he tell something that I can not tolerate it any more
  • Wait and watch
  • Aggravation: Do not give any medicine which increases my disease

Fear / Fright / Dread

Fear vs Fright

Fear of fright

Rubrics

  • Fear is About a future happening
  • Fright is due to past. He has bad experience / Aggravation and does not want to do something which ends in that experience
  • Most of Op disease triggered with a fright
  • They are afraid of agg so they do not come to Homeopathy.
  • I had a bad experience when I was a child. I do not want it is repeated.
  • Here the patient had a fright "Experience in the past"" and now he fears if he would have it again in the future
  • "Anxiety fright after": I become scared when I encounter with any of my old symptoms
  • It is very similar to Anticipation anxiety
  • Fear, fright, previous fright, because of: Acon, Bell, Nat-m, Op, Verat
  • Anxiety, fright remains, if the fear of the fright
  • Torpor, menses, suppressed from fright; in menses
  • Unconsciousness , menses, suppression of, from fright
  • Frightened , eyes, on closing

Other Rubrics

Alternating states

Deliriums / Visual dellusions

Threatened

One Remedy

  • Anger, alternating with antics playing
  • Anger, alternating with cheerfulness
  • Anger, alternating with exhilaration
  • Anger, seizes the hands of those about him
  • Cares, alternating with exhilaration
  • Exhilaration, alternating with grief blissful perspiration, during
  • Sadness, alternating with playing antics
  • Insanity, alternating with stupor
  • Delirium, cold, after catching
  • Delirium, devils, sees
  • Delirium, epilepsy, during
  • Delirium, rolls on floor specters, sees
  • Del, dragons, of
  • Del, whirling everything round him; he is whirling with
  • Activity, dream, like a - perspiration, during
  • Del, drunk, is, smoke in brain; from
  • Gesture, grasping, picks at bedclothes, dreams, during - sleep, during
  • Del, execute him, people want to
  • Del, execute sliding impelled by an invisible agent; he is sliding along the ground
  • Del, criminal, executed, to be
  • Del, stabbed, somebody threatened to stab him; as if
  • Jealousy, people around, of
  • Bites, arms, bites own
  • Cursing, afternoon
  • Del, double being, conquer the other; there were another self and he is not sure which will
  • Del, talking, she herself; she is talking with
  • Forgetful, connection of consecutive thoughts, of, apoplexy after
  • Content, night, forgets all his ailments and pains and quiet

Witty

Del, Criminal he is a, Executed to be


as